How to Make Jersey Mike's Italian Sub at Home {But Better} (2023)

Go to the recipePrint recipe

Jersey Mike's Italian Substitute was the first copycat recipe we tried. However, he didn't know that at the time. There are so many great diners and diners along the east coast and Jersey Mikes is one of them. Nothing compares to the original Jersey Shore Subs. One of our favorite spots is the White House Side Store in Atlantic City.

Table of contents

  • See how we made Jersey Mikes
  • Italy Sub-Mikes Kit Review
  • Check out the Jersey Mikes sub review
  • oven rolls
  • what's in jersey mikes sub italian
  • What type of meat do Jersey Mikes use?
  • Jersey Mike Juice
  • How to Make Jersey Mike's Italian Sub at Home
  • Do it Mike's way
  • Jersey Mike's Italian Sub Recipe
  • demolition kitchen
  • More recipes to try

See how we made Jersey Mikes

How to Make Jersey Mike's Italian Sub at Home {But Better} (1)

The biggest problem we had in creating this copied recipe was deciding whether to call it sandwich or sandwich. sub went.

Italy Sub-Mikes Kit Review

We're looking for a place that makes a great Italian substitute. One thing that is crucial for us is bread. It should be soft but have a great bite. The sub we ordered was the original Italian sub and it did everything that was promised. Good selection of cold cuts, sliced ​​thin enough to form layers.

This is what a jersey substitute should taste like. You can order the sub as you like. With mayonnaise, of course. But we ordered it Mike's way. We are fans and will be back for the cheesesteak soon. The regular one was good for me, but next time I'll go for the giant.

Check out the Jersey Mikes sub review

oven rolls

Building a Jersey Mikes Italian Sub requires the best of fundamentals to pack the meat, cheese and toppings. The bread is the base on which the sub rests. look no further thanlovingbaked Italian rolls. Now Jersey Mikes bake their own buns every day, but you can find great Italian buns in many supermarkets and grocery stores.

One of the things we really like about amoroso buns is that they're baked in-house. Cooking by the fireplace creates a slightly irregular bun. Each roll is unique when it comes out of the oven and has a wonderful flavor and texture when it's on the grill.

(Video) How To Make Jersey Mikes Italian Sub {But Better} Copycat Recipe

what's in jersey mikes sub italian

How to Make Jersey Mike's Italian Sub at Home {But Better} (2)

Most Italian meat sandwiches are similar in that each sandwich can be slightly different, but all contain a variety of Italian meats and cheeses. The Jersey Mikes Italian Deli Sub has: provolone, ham, prosciutto, capocollo, salami and pepperoni. It took me a while to realize that the ham in the sub is regular, plain ham.

What type of meat do Jersey Mikes use?

In May 2019, Jersey Mikes announced that all pork products will be antibiotic free and will be distributed by Clemons Food Group. The pig is vegetarian and the pigs are raised on American family farms distributed by Farm Promise.

We are very impressed with Jersey Mike's commitment to this program and the excellent quality of all meats, breads, vegetables and cheeses served in the restaurant. Very nice people!

Instead of using pepperoni pizza on your sandwich, order sliced ​​pepperoni from the grocery store counter.

Meat and cheese should be sliced ​​thin enough that you can stack them in smooth layers. I have my deli pick number 2 on the thin sandwich slicer.

For the cheese slices. Provolone cheese. That's all. Also thinly sliced, just like the meat slices.

Jersey Mike Juice

How to Make Jersey Mike's Italian Sub at Home {But Better} (3)

Mike's Way involves making a sandwich with onions, lettuce, tomatoes, spices, and a mixture of olive oil and red wine vinegar that the restaurant calls "El Jugo." There is no magic in making this juice. But it's magic!

It's an easy recipe to usegood extra virgin olive oil and red wine vinegar. The proportions in the recipe are 3 parts oil to 2 parts vinegar. Just watch, or make some dressing ahead of time by mixing oil, vinegar, oregano, and salt in a bowl and setting aside.

The last time we were with the Jersey Mikes, the team just rocked. Nice to see the enthusiasm for the sauce jars!

How to Make Jersey Mike's Italian Sub at Home

How to Make Jersey Mike's Italian Sub at Home {But Better} (4)

To make your Jersey Mikes Cold Cut Italian Substitute at home, prep it by chopping the lettuce, tomatoes, and onions. The onion should be sliced ​​thinly and then soaked in water to remove some of the raw onion bite. Jersey Mikes use white onions in their sandwiches, but we chose a slightly milder red onion for our sauce. Just a slight variation on the original classic sub.

Cut the Italian buns in half completely, so the two halves are completely separate. This makes assembling the sandwich easier instead of trying to stuff all the ingredients into a sub-roller envelope.

Start by assembling the Hoagie, inserting the Provolone first. The cheese acts as a barrier for the juice and keeps the sandwich from becoming soggy.

After the cheese has set, carefully place the meat on top so the sandwich is light and well-filled.

How to Make Jersey Mike's Italian Sub at Home {But Better} (5)

Do it Mike's way

To make an original Mikes Way Italian Substitute, top the sandwich with shredded lettuce, sliced ​​onions, tomatoes and the juice. Finally sprinkle the tomatoes lightly with dried oregano and some salt.


Cover the bottom with the top bun and cut the bottom in half.

Get ready to enjoy the best tasting sub you've ever tasted. But make sure you invite your significant other to share your sub or you'll be in the kennel for a while! That's a mistake I won't make again.

Jersey Mike's Italian Sub Recipe

How to Make Jersey Mike's Italian Sub at Home {But Better} (6)


Jersey Mikes Italian Cold Cut Sandwich is a classic Philadelphia-style Italian hoagie. Soft oven baked Italian bread, Italian meats and cheeses doused with juice.

Print recipepin reciperecipe rate

construction time:30 Protocol

Total time:30 Protocol

Course:Bun, snack


Keyword:CopyCat, Jersey Mikes, Subs

(Video) Why are Deli Subs better than homemade ones?




  • 2 italian buns
  • 4 ounces Provolone cheese
  • 4 ounces Ham domestic
  • 4 ounces Genoa-Salami
  • 4 ounces alleged boss
  • 4 ounces Ham
  • 4 ounces Peppers sliced ​​cold cuts
  • 1 Kopf iceberg lettuce
  • 1 impostor Red onion
  • 1 large Tomato
  • 1 soup spoon Extra virgin olive oil
  • 1 soup spoon red wine vinegar
  • 1 teaspoon Dried oregano
  • ½ teaspoon sal kosher


  • Cut the secondary rolls in half.

  • Chop and grate the iceberg lettuce.

  • Cut the tomatoes.

  • Cut the onion into thin slices.

  • Start with the provolone cheese, then add the rest of the meat. Distribute all types of meat and cheese evenly on the base.

    (Video) The $2 Sub Sandwich | But Cheaper

  • Cover the meat with onion slices, then lettuce and tomatoes.

  • Pour or shake olive oil, red wine vinegar over the spices.

  • Season the sub with a pinch of oregano and salt.

  • Cover the sub with the remaining slice of the roll. Halve and enjoy!


Calories:758kcal|Carbohydrates:24Grammatik|Protein:40Grammatik|Gordo:55Grammatik|Saturated Fatty Acids:20Grammatik|Transfette:1Grammatik|Cholesterol:126milligram|Sodium:2702milligram|Potassium:750milligram|Phases:3Grammatik|Zucker:6Grammatik|Vitamin A:1324user interface|Vitamin C:10milligram|Football:270milligram|Ferro:8milligram

Have you tried this recipe yet?inform ushow was it!

Here it is. A taste of what we say in Maryland "on the Ocean," a freshly baked Italian bread that's a little crunchy on the outside but soft and chewy on the inside. Freshly sliced ​​Italian meats and cheeses carefully selected for fat, seasoning and flavor. Finish with crispy Mike's Way Greens and juice to tie it all together. Yes, can we please do another one?

Life is beautiful when you eat a good sandwich

Keanu Reeves
How to Make Jersey Mike's Italian Sub at Home {But Better} (7)

demolition kitchen

Throwdown Kitchen is the cooking show with quick and easy recipes for everyone to enjoy. Casual dining and daily entertainment are for friends and family. People understand that and we hope you do too.

We live in incredible times and a lot is happening in the food scene. It's cooking again and if you're here, then we have something in common. The love of food and caring for family and friends. So let's cook!

Have you tried this Jersey Mikes Italian Substitute Recipe yet? Feel free to leave a 5 star rating and I'd love to hear your thoughts in the comments below.

More recipes to try

If you enjoyed this Jersey Mike's Italian Sub copycat recipe, we think you might enjoy these easy to make recipes.

  • How to Make a Jimmy Johns Bootlegger at Home {But Better}
  • Easy to prepare tortellini en brodo with spinach and tomatoes
  • Fed Donut Fried Chicken Sandwich Copycat Recipe {But Better}
  • Easy to make Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ Chicken in the oven

You can see this review atWIN



1. How to Make Proper Hoagie Rolls at home
(Ethan Chlebowski)
2. Jersey Mikes Club Sub Copycat Recipe
(Mary Walker)
3. How to Make Toasted Italian Sub Sandwiches
(Toasted Officially)
4. HOW TO MAKE THE BEST ITALIAN SUB | Best Italian Sandwich Recipe
(Mortadella Head)
(Vel Dogg's Kitchen)
6. The Perfect Philly Cheesesteak At Home (2 Ways)
(Joshua Weissman)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Dr. Pierre Goyette

Last Updated: 04/15/2023

Views: 5712

Rating: 5 / 5 (50 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Dr. Pierre Goyette

Birthday: 1998-01-29

Address: Apt. 611 3357 Yong Plain, West Audra, IL 70053

Phone: +5819954278378

Job: Construction Director

Hobby: Embroidery, Creative writing, Shopping, Driving, Stand-up comedy, Coffee roasting, Scrapbooking

Introduction: My name is Dr. Pierre Goyette, I am a enchanting, powerful, jolly, rich, graceful, colorful, zany person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.